Search
Reboot Blog Recent Titles
« Are you Becoming Your Facebook Profile? | Main | Jesus' Facebook Page »
Sunday
Apr112010

Do Video Games Make Us Smart?

Last week I participated in a public debate that considered whether technology is making us dumb (e.g. The Dumbest Generation by Mark Bauerlein).  I, of course, was tasked with the argument "technology is actually good for us".  Needless to say, it was not an easy task--until I came upon "Everything Bad is Good for You" by Steve Johnson.  One of his most compelling arguments has to do with the increasing cognitive demands of video games.  According to Johnson, video games are truly making us smarter.  While that argument is not the most obvious, after spending spring break with my gamer son and a new video game he thought I might "like", I am drawn to agree with him.

Because my son feels like one of his jobs is to train his mother in the intricacies and beauties of living in a high-tech world, he introduced me to a new game he thought might just be my speed--in other words it wasn't very hard, involved cute little aliens, and required very little hand-eye coordination. He got me to the beginning point and said "now, mom...all you have to do is get your guy over the chasm and into the other room.  You may have to replicate the guy and get a jet pack, but that's pretty easy. I'll let you work on it for a few minutes, then I'll come back to see how you are doing." I figured well, I do have a PhD, after all, how hard can this be? After being killed at least 50 times, I yelled at the t.v. screen and declared "I quit!"  I could see the disappointment in my son's eyes.  He showed me how to do a few basic maneuvers and I said "well, you didn't tell me I could do that!"  His response was "mom, you're supposed to figure that out for yourself. That's part of the game."

He was right.  Video games are not for those who want to sit back and tune out intellectually.  Most games are full of cognitive complexity. They require patience and step by step goal setting with layer after layer of problems to be solved.  The gamer has to figure out the rules of the game (the days of things like chess where you know the rules ahead of time are long gone).  He or she has to determine the "physics of the virtual world".  In other words, by trial and error, he or she figures out what it takes to fly, speed, shoot, walk, fight, and stay alive.  According to Johnson, gamers begin by exploring the world; they then define problems, make hypotheses, test them out, revise hypotheses and act upon the findings.  Does that remind you of anything familiar?  That would be the scientific method.  That's right, as our kids are sitting around with controllers in their hands and blank looks on their faces, they are actually refining important problem-solving techniques that have a direct application to real-life issues.

As I was making these arguments in my recent debate, a young man raised his hand and asked if these skills  are really transferable or valuable?  The same could be asked of the types of problems we have students do in math and science classes.  After all, how many times, in real life, will our kids have to figure out if 2 trains left a station 100 miles apart and one traveled 60 mph......?  The point is, we are training our kids how to think.  How is that different than what the video games are doing?

My conclusion? There is ALOT more to video games than what most people assume.  Though they may have addictive powers and may contain violence and lots of well-endowed stereotypical women, they are also challenging our kids to think in ways that are much more significant than checkers or Uno. So the next time you see a kid (or a spouse) sitting and playing a video game, take a breathe before you tell him or her to get off that thing and get a life.  He or she may just be getter smarter with every level that is conquered and every task that is mastered.

References (12)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    Response: Habbo hack
    Technology and Faith - Blog - Do Video Games Make Us Smart?
  • Response
    Technology and Faith - Blog - Do Video Games Make Us Smart?
  • Response
    Response: hair weaves
    Guide to Achieve Salon Quality Hair Styling Results from Karmin G3 Flat Iron hair extensions Karmin G3 Flat I curly wigs ron ?launched by Karmin ?is a recent addition in the flat iron industry. Even though it is relatively new to the industry, this styler has ...
  • Response
    Technology and Faith - Blog - Do Video Games Make Us Smart?
  • Response
    Response: click this
    Technology and Faith - Blog - Do Video Games Make Us Smart?
  • Response
    Technology and Faith - Blog - Do Video Games Make Us Smart?
  • Response
    Response: UK Models Review
    Technology and Faith - Blog - Do Video Games Make Us Smart?
  • Response
    Response: SEO in Portland OR
    Technology and Faith - Blog - Do Video Games Make Us Smart?
  • Response
    Response: mahjong set
    Technology and Faith - Blog - Do Video Games Make Us Smart?
  • Response
    Response: Arabella Albir
    Arabella Albir
  • Response
    Response: IGI 3
  • Response

Reader Comments (26)

I disagree with the video games making people smarter. Maybe they are becoming more skilled in playing but that doesn't make them smarter or better educated. Look at the high school kids that are very versed in playing games but are unable to read and write above the eighth grade level. David

July 31, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterDave Thorn

While that may be true, according to Steve Johnson, they are still becoming proficient in skills that are necessary in today's world. Clearly, reading and writing are skills everyone needs to have and if gamers don't have those skills, they won't get too far. On the other hand, they may be using their minds in ways that are much more sophisticated than we give them credit for. The real key is to help them figure out how to transfer those problem-solving skills from the virtual world and use them for success in the real world.
-Peggy

August 4, 2010 | Registered CommenterPeggy Kendall

I recently came accross your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I dont know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.

April 27, 2011 | Unregistered Commentercartier necklace love

I recently came accross your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I dont know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.

Good writing, and I very much agree with your thoughts and insights. Hope that more could write such a good word, I said, to continue coming to visit, thank you for sharing.

July 1, 2011 | Unregistered Commentermodischepandora

Your article very good, I like, thank you for sharing, I hope you write a better article, I will continue to concern. Also thank you for your attention

Your article very good, I like, thank you for sharing, I hope you write a better article, I will continue to concern. Also thank you for your attention
ASH Mens Sneaker cheap

July 5, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterash shoes

Ihr Artikel ist sehr gut, ich mag es, weil es sinnvoll ist. Vielen Dank für den Austausch, ich glaube, Sie schreiben eine bessere Artikel werden. ich setzte Bedenken noch fort. Auch ich danke Ihnen für Ihre Aufmerksamkeit
Chanel Tasche
Chanel Sammlung in Boutique

July 21, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterbillige chanel Tasche

like it.thanks for sharing....
Chanel Messenger Bags
Chanel Long Wallets

July 26, 2011 | Unregistered Commentercheap chanel handbags

Your article very good, I like, thank you for sharing, I hope you write a better article, I will continue to concern. Also thank you for your attention
Buy Womens True Religion Petite Jeans
Buy Womens True Religion Skinny Jeans

<p> to visit Christian Louboutin Online, I am sure you will find one that is most appropriate for you. You will be tonight princess. it mates with Christian Louboutin Pumps. The combination is perfect. Come, we await your coming. </p>
<p>Each pair of these shoes is a real amazing thing of beauty. Christian Louboutin Sandals If you want to buy these shoes.</p>
<p> you the modern range of Discount Christian Louboutin Boots: excellent design, superior quality and more than reasonable prices. Christian Louboutin silver leather is your eye-catcher, more and more to pay more attention to it. Discount Louboutin Pumps offers the best service and quality.</p>
<p> Many first-class people wear such shoes to meet their formal evening gowns when present some official parties. The designs of shoes are unique and memorable so that they can make you different, whether you're a star or just a common people.Cheap Louboutin Sandals not only can make you smart.High heels are never out of fashion because it is the fashion brand. Whatever the season, they are still selling hot.Cheap Louboutin Ankle Boots from our shop is the best-seller. </p>
<p>Fashion is the main theme of the lives of women. They have great interest and fashion trends very carefully on fashionable clothes, shoes, jewelry, etc.. At the mention of shoes, I think a lot of people think the luxury brand shoes, Christian Louboutin High Heels. The most unique Cheap Christian Louboutin Boots plant is painted red. Since the early 1990s until now, this kind of shoes are widely used by many top-class people. </p>

August 5, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterChristian shoes

Want to learn HTML language will cheshi W3School < / a >

August 9, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterpryifu

geschehen habe ich ihren Artikel gelesen,mag ich sehr,so habe ich diese geschrieben,danke fuer den Austausch!
Chanel Kleinlederwaren
Chanel Klassiker Tasche
Chanel Tasche

August 10, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterbillige chanel Tasche

geschehen habe ich ihren Artikel gelesen

August 13, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterChanel Tasche

Your article very good, I like, thank you for sharing, I hope you write a better article, I will continue to concern. Also thank you for your attentionChanel Long Wallets
Chanel New Styler Bags 2011
Chanel Pump

August 16, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterChanel Tasche

,so habe ich diese geschrieben,danke fuer den Austausch!
Chanel Tasche
Chanel Sammlung in Boutique

The Monster dre beats Tour In-Ear Headphones have perhaps the longest earpieces we’ve

ever seen. The ‘buds measure a full inch from end to end, and half of that length is made up of the arms that hold the eartips. Half an inch isn’t that

long for most gadgets, but the scale is considerably altered when you have to stick the gadget into your ear. As a result, fit can be an issue. Although

Monster beats dre includes five sets of silicone eartips (three sizes of standard and

two sizes of triple flange), we found the beats studio Tour earphones to be fairly

uncomfortable and could never really get a secure fit. Plus, the ends of the ‘buds tend to stick out pretty far from the head.

August 22, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterbetty

Of course, fit is highly personal. One could make that argument for style, too, but there’s no denying that the dre beats diddy earphones will add quite a bit of flair to your listening setup. The entire design is unique, from the

flattened, disc-shaped earbuds–decked out in the signature lowercase “b” logo–to the red ribbon of a cable. The beats tour cord, which terminates in a gold-plated straight plug, is like few we’ve seen; flat and thick, it appears to be more

durable than most earbud cables–definitely a plus. Monster also includes a hard-sided zippered case for storing and protecting your investment when it’s

not in use.

August 22, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterlily8901

Top-line beat from the dre beats headphones can see a dazzling array of new version of the brand's star performers, ring in the new year the couple focus. Led the brand's latest project is Lady Gaga and Product (RED) program, as well as hip-hop mogul beats dr dre created together with special headphones with the movement. The line combined with the advanced architecture and advanced sonic technology to provide power, durability and extra sound insulation, up to now has been the lack of professional headphones. Details of two upcoming, by Dr. Dre beat of the site.The latest addition to Dr. Dre headphones line-up beat, ammunition and the famous hip-hop artist and producer beats dre, Interscope Chairman Jimmy Iovine and dr dre headphone and ongoing cooperation between the true partnership. In this exclusive arrangement ammunition, as a designer, entrepreneur's role in the design and music industry is unprecedented. This special partnership is to promote design changes in the industry as a viable model, designers how to play a more active role in the business and development, the parties share the risks and rewards, and other critical business functions designed to be placed above the driving products to market.

August 29, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterlily8901

eine bessere Artikel werden. Links of london womens wathes
Cheap Sweetie Watch
ch setzte Bedenken noch fort. Auch ich danke Ihnen für Ihre Aufmerksamkeit

Through your article, Chanel Sammlung in Boutique
billige Chanel online bestellenI understand they want to know. Thank you for sharing, I believe you will write a better article, I will continue to focus on your blog.

September 10, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterChanel Sammlung in Boutique

As you know Pandora discount landmark beadsare wonderful destinations when it comes to gift something special. In fact, it's perfect when it comes to fashion. Sterling silver lighthouse pandora charm are sure to make stand out, because it gives you a chance to show off your individual style. You can also celebrate special events and opportunities for creating pandora like charm bracelets.

December 1, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterbetty

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.